A Synodal Church Needs Real Structures for Listening

In recent years, the Church has spoken with renewed clarity about the importance of listening as a constitutive part of her life and mission. This emphasis has not emerged from theory or trend, but from lived pastoral reality. The Church recognizes that evangelization and renewal suffer when voices are unheard and discernment is confined to too small a circle.

This is the context in which the Church has lifted up synodality with fresh urgency.

The work of the Synod on Synodality makes clear that listening is not an abstract ideal, but a concrete responsibility. The Synod’s Final Synthesis notes that:

“Synodality is not an end in itself but a way of being Church, oriented toward mission” (§1).

Listening, in this vision, is not optional. It is integral to how the Church discerns and acts.

At the parish level, this vision raises an unavoidable question: Where does listening actually happen?

The Synod is explicit that synodality cannot rely on goodwill alone. It requires real practices and real structures. As the Final Synthesis states:

“Structures of participation, such as pastoral councils, are essential to fostering a synodal Church” (§70).

Did you read what I just read? Pastoral and Finance Councils are a tool to becoming a more synodal parish.

This language is important. Councils are not described as helpful accessories or administrative conveniences. When structured correctly, councils are named as essential instruments for participation, listening, discernment, and shared responsibility.

Without such structures, listening often becomes informal and uneven. Certain voices are heard consistently, while others remain invisible. Decisions are shaped by urgency, habit, or proximity rather than prayerful reflection. Over time, this weakens trust and limits the Church’s ability to respond faithfully to new pastoral realities.

Parish councils help address this gap by giving listening a home.

But that is far from the lived reality of many parishes. More thought, energy, and resources are required in support of developing healthy councils that move the mission of the Church forward.

Reflection: What’s your experience with pastoral and finance councils? Do you see their potential, or are they mere obstacles or inconveniences to manage?

Meet John Rinaldo

John brings decades of lived experience serving and accompanying Church leaders across diverse ministry contexts. His work is rooted in listening, discernment, and faithful leadership shaped by real parish and diocesan life.

Join the Newsletter

Receive short leadership insights and practical ministry reflections delivered to your inbox. Stay encouraged, stay aligned, and keep growing in your mission.