The Top Five Parish Problems (That everybody has and nobody wants to talk about)

What happens when two parish consultants get together and get honest about the chronic problems they see in parishes? The conversation gets interesting!

My friend, John Poitevent (Great Catholic Parishes) and myself, John Rinaldo from Santa Clara University, had a candid, engaging, and occasionally humorous conversation about the five most common challenges we encounter in our work with parishes, particularly in leadership. From unproductive meeting and dysfunctional team dynamics to dealing with rogue volunteers and ministries, we discuss why these problems persist, and practical ideas for addressing them. No jargon, no sugarcoating—just two experienced consultants talking shop and sharing insights to help parish leaders lead more effectively and build healthier, more vibrant parishes.

This was a lot of fun to record! So much so, that I wanted to share it with you all here. I encourage you to watch the entire webinar for some great detail, but I thought I’d share each of our top 5 parish problems here below. This is just a bullet point of them, so I encourage you to watch the webinar to get great details and how to solve these problems.

John Poitevent’s Top 5:

5. Digital Communication

4. Legacy Parish Leaders

3. Bad Meetings/Not Enough Meetings

2. Lack of accountability

1. Lack of Mission/Vision

John Rinaldo’s Top 5:

5. Death by meetings

4. Mass executed poorly

3. No Vision

2. Staff does everything

1. Avoiding problem people

Enjoy the webinar!

Meet John Rinaldo

John brings decades of lived experience serving and accompanying Church leaders across diverse ministry contexts. His work is rooted in listening, discernment, and faithful leadership shaped by real parish and diocesan life.

Join the Newsletter

Receive short leadership insights and practical ministry reflections delivered to your inbox. Stay encouraged, stay aligned, and keep growing in your mission.