Photo by Ann H: https://www.pexels.com/photo/yellow-scrabble-tiles-1888021/

Before You Recruit: Why Your Volunteer “Problem” Is Actually a Preparation Problem

Before you put out an open call for volunteers, post a bulletin announcement, or make a single phone call, you need to stop and ask a critical question: Are you actually ready for volunteers?

Too often in ministry, we jump straight into recruitment mode because we are drowning. We feel like Moses crying out in the wilderness in Numbers 11: “Why have you afflicted your servant?” We feel overwhelmed, there is too much work on our plates, and we just need warm bodies to lighten the load. However, if we do not lay the groundwork first, we end up in a frustrating loop: recruiting people in a panic, only to watch them drop out a few months later.

Before launching any new recruitment effort, you must take two foundational steps to prepare your ministry.

1. Assess Your Current Efforts

You cannot move forward until you know where you currently stand. Grab a pen and conduct an honest inventory:

  • Count your current volunteers:
    • How many volunteers do you have total?
        • How many are key leaders who take initiative?
        • How many are occasional helpers who show up only when asked? (BTW, you need both).
  • Define your true need: How many volunteers do you actually need to accomplish your mission—not just to keep existing programs on life support, but to move the needle?
  • Track your turnover: How many volunteers have dropped out or walked away in the last year?

If people are leaving, we have to be willing to look deeply at this and see what the issue is. There are likely system issues that you have control over.

2. Shift Your Foundational Mindset

Working with volunteers requires an intentional mindset shift long before you draft a schedule. First, stop believing the myth that “nobody wants to help anymore” or that there are not enough volunteers. There are plenty of gifted people in our communities. Our challenge is finding the right people for the right roles.

Second, remember that we are called to trust and enable volunteers, not simply use them as free labor. Ask yourself: What is their value to our organization beyond saving us time?

Finally, how will you ensure a healthy working relationship between staff and volunteers, and among the volunteers themselves? How will you guarantee that serving in your ministry is a rewarding experience?

Recruiting is not about filling empty slots on an organizational chart; it is about inviting people into co-responsibility for the mission. Once your mindset and self-assessment are aligned, you can begin building the actual structure to support them.

Reflection: Take time to do the analysis about your true volunteer needs. This will allow you to see your ministry in a more complete way.

Meet John Rinaldo

John brings decades of lived experience serving and accompanying Church leaders across diverse ministry contexts. His work is rooted in listening, discernment, and faithful leadership shaped by real parish and diocesan life.

Join the Newsletter

Receive short leadership insights and practical ministry reflections delivered to your inbox. Stay encouraged, stay aligned, and keep growing in your mission.